same old body

William James – the nineteenth centure pioneer of Psychology – wrote the following:

Contrary to the perception of an object, which can be perceived from different perspectives or even cease to be perceived, we experience “the feeling of the same old body always there”

– William James

There’s something about the way in which we take our bodies for granted in James’ statement. That we tend to think of our bodies as consistent and constant (rather than fabulous Ships of Theseus).

Yet, in this work – and in much movement work that focuses on sensitising the body as it feels – there is nothing ‘same old’ about it. The feeling is more like an ongoing refreshing of the body in which what is new or different or fresh or distinct (whether it be temperature, position, friction, weight, tingling, movement) manifests a same new body.


Comments

6 responses to “same old body”

  1. Here I am again with the same old, new, old body, rising once more for a new morning that looks and feels a lot like yesterday, or some moment of a morning a decade ago. And yet I know I haven’t been here, exactly, before.

    1. thank you Kat. It’s that word “exactly” at the end that I love so much. It’s not exactly the same.

      1. That intuitive recognition of one’s place in time, present. The history and the future converging around this “same oldness”. Deep belly recognition of “here I am, repeating with difference”. Deleuze Repetition and Difference coming in strong for me here.

        1. Perhaps one of the things that is messing with my head (beautifully) in this project is who the “I” is in a statement like “here I am”, and how does one know that location? Indeed, when I say “my head” it’s not at all clear that ‘my head’ is anything more than a collection of sensations: pressure, temperature, movement, tingling. The “my head” is a construction to help the entity-that-is-me to survive.

  2. Sue Davies avatar
    Sue Davies

    I look at the fast fast changing bodies of my grand children.
    The tiny alterations which will let the youngest take his own weight and take a step or two on his own.
    His facial expressions change as well, although that is partially copying ours. But his body has to be ready for that first step.
    He is super concious of his lack of stability whereas the eldest aged 4 relies totally on the safety of her body as she hurtles step to step , not same old , same old yet!

    1. not yet, and hopefully not ever. Fresh and re-fresh. xx

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *